Yugoslavia existed for decades before it was torn apart by ethnic tensions which would’ve happened regardless of what economic system they used.
Communalist towns were largely stable up until they basically aged out of functioning due to birthrate issues. Lots of them were weird little religious communities which are just kinda subject to population collapse.
Black Ukraine didn’t last long enough to really do much of anything because of the Bolsheviks, could’ve failed or succeeded but it’s impossible to tell which what would’ve happened.
Syndicalist neighborhoods were almost all wiped out by the Pinkertons. But the ones that lasted the longest were well on track to democratically seizing some cities and townships.
I chose my list the way I did because none of them failed due to the system themselves, they either collapsed due to pre-existing social issues or were destroyed by outside forces.
Yugoslavia existed for decades before it was torn apart by ethnic tensions which would’ve happened regardless of what economic system they used.
Communalist towns were largely stable up until they basically aged out of functioning due to birthrate issues. Lots of them were weird little religious communities which are just kinda subject to population collapse.
Black Ukraine didn’t last long enough to really do much of anything because of the Bolsheviks, could’ve failed or succeeded but it’s impossible to tell which what would’ve happened.
Syndicalist neighborhoods were almost all wiped out by the Pinkertons. But the ones that lasted the longest were well on track to democratically seizing some cities and townships.
I chose my list the way I did because none of them failed due to the system themselves, they either collapsed due to pre-existing social issues or were destroyed by outside forces.