I am being absolutely serious here with the Weimar Republic comparison. Because people are fucking miserable and it’s fucking terrifying.
A hundred years ago, broke people in big cities would go to fascist rallies because they were free, and because sometimes the organizers gave out free food and beer, and because people had nothing better to do.
And they stayed because hate feels good when you’re hurting and simple violent solutions appeal to the angry monkey parts of our brains.
And the fewer community connections you have - the more the economy strips your life down to work and sleep, or to job hunting and sleep, or to scrounging in the gutter to survive and sleep, and the less you go out and socialize with actual human beings - the more appealing the fascist illusion of unity, of being part of a powerful group, becomes.
And the only difference today is that the fascist rallies are beamed directly into your home.
Pretty much, yeah.
Fascism, at its core, is Us versus Them. Under all the complexities and layers is one simple idea: Our problems are because They have Our resources, and we need a strong leader to go to war (figuratively or literally) against Them and take Our stuff.
And I think this is incredibly seductive because it triggers our old hominid instincts, from back when we lived in small tribes on the African savannah, and when our territory was hit by drought, or fire, or natural disaster, and we didn’t have enough resources, the solution really was to go into another tribe’s territory, drive them out, and take their stuff.
Lebensraum is as old as stone knives and bearskins.
And the more desperate people are, the more frightened and hungry and angry they are, the stronger those old animal instincts become.
But, you know, a good leader can simplify complicated issues. A good leader can identify problems, articulate actual solutions, and direct people’s angry monkey brains towards fighting for those solutions instead of persecuting scapegoats. Not Us versus Them, but All of Us, together, fighting poverty and climate change and economic hardship and building a better future.
Unfortunately, in the United States and the “free world” as a whole, we have a handful of extraordinarily wealthy people who benefit from all the economic and social failures that are causing the problems we suffer from. And they want people to believe in a simple violent solution that blames the wrong people and doesn’t actually fix anything, because they don’t want the problems fixed.
And you don’t get elected unless these extraordinarily wealthy people give you enough money to win an election.
So we don’t get any good leaders. We get a choice between fascism and the status quo, which is also fascism.
Yay, democracy.